Our Sugar Matchmaking Reviews From Yelp
For 15 years Sugar Matchmaking has delivered private introductions, dating advice and relationship coaching to over 1,000 clients. We maintain the highest satisfaction rating among elite personal matchmaking firms. Client privacy and discretion remain non-negotiable. Public reviews are therefore rare.
Kelly S. Park City, UT
January 5, 2014
My friends and I love successful men but it is so hard to find ones that know how to spoil a woman correctly. I joined sugar matchmaking and met great guys, had amazing adventures and got the excitement I craved. The men are classy, smart, successful and love to spoil. Its the only matchmaking club of its kind and I went on an adventure to Vegas with Sugar Matchmaking and found the perfect man. Mr. Right and I are still seeing each other and looking forward to a summer abroad. Thank you Sugar Matchmaking, your right, dating taste sweeter with rewards. I would recommend this to men and women who seek exciting fulfilling non traditional relationship where they can be who they really are. The screening process was great and the caliber of men better than any others I have ever met.
Robert M. Philadelphia, PA
September 2, 2014
I was sick of online dating and decided to try sugar matchmaking. It was life changing the matchmakers and coaches are first rate and the women are stunning. I went out with actual models and had the best time. I enjoyed that you could define the relationship and casual dating beautiful women is something I always wanted to try. The gorgeous matchmakers give great advice and really know how to find the perfect match.
Donald B. Beverly Hills, CA
January 16, 2019
I was very pleased with the services I received. I was frustrated with all the online websites when trying to find an attractive woman to spoil and be spoiled back. Sugar Matchmaking screening process is amazing and they were able to match me with four different girls, all of whom there was an attraction to. I highly recommend Sugar Matchmaking to anybody who wants to do this exciting type of dating! They even coached me on various aspects of the relationship which was a tremendous help.
Chris B. Chicago, IL
June 11, 2019
I had two great experiences with Sugar Matchmaking 5 years apart. I contacted them in 2014 to help me find an on going sugar relationship with a 20’s something intelligent and attractive lady. They did just that and the relationship lasted almost 5 years. It only ended because Kelly the young lady got a great job on the east coast. I recently recontacted them to help me with the same thing and they have introduced me to several amazing women that I am thoroughly enjoying getting to know. They are very good at what they do and compared to some of the other matchmaking companies are more reasonably priced and deliver more. I have also used there coaching services which are superior at helping navigate these unique relationships. I have met a total of 14 women through the service for at least one date and although each one is very different they were all as described by Sugar Matchmaking. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a mutual beneficial on going relationship or Elite casual dating in general.
Jimmie P. Houston, TX
May 14, 2020
Sugar Matchmaking is the best service out there! If you are excited about meeting quality pretty girls, contact Sugar Matchmaking! Their matchmakers are professional and it was very enjoyable to work with them. They are sweet and kind and their matchmakers made it easy for me. They patiently walked me through the process, until I met the perfect lady for me. They learned my desires and needs to get the best possible match that suits me. I am very happy with the service and looking forward to working with them again.
Kevin T. San Diego, CA
April 24, 2020
Finding sugar love during covid19 pandemic I am an elderly gentleman with some experience in mutually beneficial dating. I never had any real luck with it, it seems I always picked the wrong woman. With the current events of the world I was left with a tremendous amount of time on my hands, I discovered Sugar Matchmaking. I spoke to them at length about my concerns, health, travel, finances, chemistry and they listened attentively. I asked dozens upon dozens of questions, thoroughly researched the company, and signed up for their VIP package. They did a nationwide search for my match; I met several beautiful women via video call and formed some great relationships. I have decided upon Sarah, 35, a nurse who has beauty, charm, and grace. We have become fast companions and developed a true friendship. Thanks to Sugar Matchmaking during the worldwide lockdown, there is still fun to be had at home with my quarantine girl.
Scott B. Baton Rouge, LA
May 3, 2020
This company helped find the girl I was searching for my entire life. I was becoming frustrated on the sugar websites and had so many girls turn out to be something different than what they said they were. I finally found this company that screens the girls and has girls coming to them. It seemed to good to be true but after a couple times on the phone and over an hour call where they gave me a complete understanding of the process, I signed up. They set me up with 5 dynamic gorgeous girls and a 6 one I fell head over heels for. She was everything I had been looking for in sugar dating and I was what she had been longing for. We had chemistry, attraction, common goals and interests. This was to good to be true but I remembered what my matchmaker said we listen to both of you and match not just on a type of look but the complete package. She is that…..the “Complete Package!” The matchmaker was right we are still together almost a year later. Thank you for listening and getting me something real. The new management at the company really takes pride in matching for ongoing and actually still give me some tips when they check in on me. It feels like a friend not a company.
Antonio V. Pinellas Park, FL
March 12, 2026
Great coaching from Katrina. I have used their service for several years and learned a lot about elite dating which really helped my confidence. They matched me with a wonderful women.
Peter W. Albany, NY
March 13, 2026
I had a good experience with Sugarmatchmaking.com. As a busy professional, I didn’t have the time to deal with dating apps, so having a service that handled introductions made things much easier. I met three or four different women through the process, and the coaching from Patrick was a big part of what made it work. He broke everything down in simple, practical terms and made it easy to understand how to communicate and interact in a way that felt natural. One of those introductions ended up turning into something much more serious, and she’s now my soon-to-be wife. Overall the process was discreet, straightforward, and convenient. Not perfect, but definitely a solid experience, which is why I’m giving four stars. For what I received from this or paid anything to meet my wife soon to be, a little out of my league and it still makes me nervous, but I thank God every day thanks, Patrick
Sandra W. Kihei, HI
March 17, 2026
I’ve been a VIP client of sugarmatchmaking.com for 6 months. It took some time but it was SO worth it!! Coaching with Katrina taught me how to navigate elite dating. I’ve been connected with an amazing SD, he takes EXCELLENT care of me. He’s an amazing guy; very kind compassionate, very generous & happy to help with any needs. This service has by far exceeded my expectations. I definitely recommend
Steve C. Murrells Inlet, SC
April 22, 2026
I debated for a long time if this company could work for me. I have no idea how to date in 2026. I’m an older guy and be honest not that attractive. I originally signed up for some dating coaching for sugar dating last year. In February I took the plunge for having Sugar Matchmaking do a search to find a woman who would like to have a relationship with me. It’s only been a short time but it’s absolutely amazing. I never thought I could get someone as beautiful as Allison and as kind who truly appreciates me. Katrina is an mazing coach and really helped me to not be nervous. I went on three dates the first two were just okay but the woman I now have my life I hope to keep is what I’ve always dreamed of.